{geni:about_me} Other cousins have her married twice and with child. If not her who is her son mother, and father? More research is required. Perhaps wikipedia is wrong. Mistakes do get made and carried on. I do not wish to make further changes here until multiple questions are answered.

http://www.genealogienetz.de/vereine/wgff/trier/Familienbuecher/Wittlich.html#H Source of husband's name and wedding date. April 2009 REL Feb. 2015 Source no longer exist. More research needs to be done. http://compgen.de/ still exist when www.genealogienetz.de is entered. My German is not good enought to use this page. Who are these men -- Eduard Marx and Salomon Lieb?

Managers of Caroline Lieb,

I am contacting you about this profile: http://www.geni.com/people/Caroline-Lieb/4689530288460021312

http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geschwister_Marx#Caroline_Marx
Caroline Marx (* 30. Juli 1824 in Trier; † 13. Dezember 1847 in Trier) war das achte Kind von Heinrich Marx und Schwester von Karl Marx.
Caroline wurde in Trier, im Wohnhaus der Familie Simeongasse 1070 (heute Simeonstraße 8), geboren. Am 26. August 1824 wurde sie evangelisch in der elterlichen Wohnung in Trier zusammen mit ihren Geschwistern getauft. Ihre Taufpaten waren der Anwalt Friedrich Wilhelm Rupp und Frau Julie Emmerich, geb. Küppert. Über ihre Schulbildung ist nichts bekannt. Aus Briefen ihrer Schwester Sophia geht hervor, dass sie ihren Bruder Karl liebte. Auch zur Familie von Westphalen hielt sie Kontakt, so z. B. beim Tod von Jenny Marx' Bruder Carl 1840.[42] Am 12. April 1840 wurde sie in der Dreifaltigkeitskirche in Trier konfirmiert. Durch mehrere Briefe erhielt Karl Marx Informationen über den Gesundheitszustand seiner Schwester.[43] Im Juni 1844 besuchte sie Jenny Marx und ihre Tochter Jenny, als diese in Trier zu Besuch waren. Am 14. Januar starb Caroline an „Schwindsucht“[44] und wurde am 16. Januar 1847 auf dem FriedhofRuwererstraße beerdigt.[45]

She died from phtisis aged 23, still unmarried, which does not fit into the family tree

Sincerely,

Raphael Schoemann

English translation

http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geschwister_Marx#Caroline_Marx
Caroline Marx (born July 30, 1824 in Trier; † 13 December 1847 in Trier) was the eighth child of Heinrich Marx and sister of Karl Marx.
Caroline was in Trier, (now Simeonstraße 8) born in the house of Simeon alley family 1070. On 26 August 1824 she was baptized in the Protestant parents' home in Trier together with her siblings. Your godparents were the lawyer Frederick William Rupp and wife Julie Emmerich, born Küppert. About their education is not known. From letters to her sister Sophia reveals that she loved her brother Charles. Even the family von Westphalen they kept in touch, such.As the death of Jenny Marx's brother Carl, 1840. [42] On April 12, 1840, she confirmed in the Holy Trinity Church in Trier. Through several letters Karl Marx received information about the health of his sister. [43] In June 1844 visited Jenny Marx and her daughter Jenny, as they were in Trier to visit. On January 14, Caroline died of "consumption" [44] and was buried on 16 January 1847 the cemetery Ruwererstraße. [45]


Other possible identity (source http://gw.geneanet.org/luitpold?lang=fr;pz=henri+lumis;nz=appell;oc... )

Carolina (Geilgen) Marx
• Born January 19th 1801 - Butzweiler
• Deceased april 24th 1858 - Reinsport aged 57
Parents
o Josef Marx
o Helwige Lewy born in Aach, † april 15th 1816
Union(s) children
• Married february 9th 1825 , Neumagen, to Salomon Leib 1797-1861 children:
o Caroline Salomon 1826-1838
o Leib Salomon 1828-1843
 Joseph Salomon 1831-1863
o Abraham Salomon 1833-1833
o Abraham Salomon 1835
o Eva Salomon 1836-1865
 Abraham Salomon 1842-1933

Salomon Leib
• Born may 27th 1797 - Niederemmel
• Decased november 27th 1861 - Niederemmel , aged 64
Parents
• Salomon Salomon 1743-1813
• Carolina Levy 1746-1824
Siblings
• Jeanette Salomon 1796
Half siblings
Side Salomon Salomon 1743-1813

o with Freidgen Michel †1787
o Rachel Salomon 1776
 Abraham Schmitt 1778-1852
 Isaak Salomon 1784-1868

Sincerely,

Raphael Schoemann